why telling angels are female is wrong

admin

The verses you shared are exactly on point. They are Verses 18 and 19 from Surah Az-Zukhruf (Chapter 43).

These two verses read together provide a powerful critique of the pre-Islamic Arabian mindset, exposing both their theological errors and their cultural hypocrisy.

Here is a breakdown of the context and meaning behind these specific verses:

1. Exposing a Cultural Double Standard (Verse 18)

(They say,) “What is good about an offspring that is brought up to be beautiful, and cannot help in war?”

In pre-Islamic Arabian society (the time of Jahiliyyah), tribal strength, warfare, and physical defense were highly valued. Because of this, they heavily preferred having sons. Daughters, who were traditionally adorned with jewelry ("brought up to be beautiful") and did not participate in physical combat, were often viewed as a lesser blessing or even a burden by the pagan Arabs.

The Quran is pointing out a massive contradiction in their logic: How could they attribute daughters to the Almighty Creator when they themselves viewed daughters as undesirable or weak for their own tribal needs?

2. The Demand for Evidence (Verse 19)

They claimed that the angels, who are servants of the Most Gracious, are females! Have they witnessed their creation? Their claims are recorded, and they will be asked.

Following the critique of their double standard, this verse directly attacks the root of their claim with basic logic.

• "Servants of the Most Gracious": The Quran re-establishes the true identity of angels. They are not God's literal children (male or female); they are simply devoted servants and creations of Allah.
• "Have they witnessed their creation?": This is a profound philosophical counter-argument. Since humans are confined to the physical world, they have absolutely no empirical proof of the unseen world (Al-Ghayb). Claiming angels are females is an invention born from human imagination and cultural projection, not from divine revelation or actual observation.
• Accountability: The verse concludes with a stern warning. Words matter, and assigning false attributes to God's creation—especially linking it to a pagan belief that God has offspring—is a serious claim for which they will be held accountable.